Top 10 Reasons People Don’t Tithe

Tithing is a spiritual discipline many Christians practice. In its simplest form it means giving back to God 10% of what you make. I’ve practiced it for years as a regular part of my giving. I tithe ‘plus’ to my local church and I give to other causes on top of that. However, throughout my 35 years of ministry I’ve seen 10 common reasons that church people give for not tithing. I list them below with a counter point below each.

  1. It’s all mine anyway. Why should I give?
    • Counter-point (CP): Everything we own is actually God’s (Ps 50.10, Ps 24.1).
  2. I give elsewhere. This is the person who counts his giving to secular causes, his time, or paying for his child’s Christian school tuition as his tithe.
    • CP: Do causes around the purposes of God get the lion’s share of your giving?
  3. Tithing is not in the New Testament. This is one of the most common.
  4. God will provide through other people. This person believes that other people will give to support the cause of Christ in their church.
    • CP: God chose to release His resources through all believers.
  5. My gifts don’t really count. This person thinks that because he can’t give much, his giving really doesn’t matter.
    • CP: Don’t minimize the size of any gift (recall the story of the poor widow in Mark 12.41-44).
  6. I don’t trust preachers. This is understandable due to the few high profile ministers who misuse God’s money.
    • CP: If you lead a church, make sure you instill the highest standards of stewardship and accountability.
  7. I only give to projects I like. This is the control freak who only gives to projects he or she can designate funds to. Some people in this category even hold back their giving in their church because they haven’t gotten their way.
    • CP: Trust your church leadership to wisely manage God’s money.
  8. I have no control over my finances. My husband does. In this case (and it’s almost always a wife in this position) her husband controls the finances and although the wife wants to give, he prohibits it.
    • CP: Rest in the Lord, He knows your heart.
  9. I will tithe when I can afford it.
  10. I’m afraid to. These people honestly fear what might happen to them or their family if they give.
    • CP: Step out in faith knowing that God promises to meet your needs.

What reasons have you heard people use to justify not giving or tithing?

Related posts:

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic.

  • Rebecca Littlejohn

    Regarding #3, the New Testament actually encourages us to give it all, not just ten percent. So that’s a pretty risky excuse to lean on!

    • Rebecca, you are exactly right. It’s all His in the first place.

  • Tony Isaac

    The reasons you’ve given seem to play more on people’s emotions than scriptural proof.

    I will start with your 3rd point. You actually didn’t provide any scriptural proof in support of New Testament tithing. The truth is, it is just not there. The usual answer I hear constantly is Jesus did abolish the law and that is very true. However, if the law has not been abolished why then do we not still observe all of it? Why have we only singled out the tithe and conveniently banished all other aspects of the law? That is double standard in my opinion.

    That aside, if we follow the trail let by scriptures about tithing we will see how far removed from scripture today’s views on the tithe are. The major reason I hear that is used in support of tithing today is that it precedes the law in that Abraham tithed to Melchizedek before the law. But we also forget that circumcision also precedes the law and why is it not also taught today? Another thing that is overlooked is; Abraham gave this voluntarily and he did not become better off for doing it nor would he have been worse off if he didn’t do it. He didn’t get any commendation from God for doing it either.

    The tithe mentioned in the book of Malachi refers exclusively to the tithe of the law. It was part and parcel of the 613 Old Testament laws. It was exclusively the TENTH part of agricultural produce grown within the land of Israel alone and never money. And this was not because money was absent as the children of Israel were allowed to buy back their tithes but had to pay its monetary value plus 20%. Those who lived far away from the venue of the tithing banquet were also allowed to convert their tithes into money and spend every single penny on wine, strong drink or on anything they liked.

    Nowhere in the New Testament do we see the tithe taught as the giving standard instead we are all enjoined to give as we are able be it 1% or 100%.

    God bless.

    • So you missed where Jesus said you should give a tithe?

      “This you should have done…”

      • Tony Isaac

        Jesus’ audience was jews who were still under the law. And the context of the discuss was not on why the NT church should tithe but the hypocrisy of the Pharisees.

        This does not build a case for NT tithing any more than Jesus’s command to the leper He healed to go show himself to the priest and offer the sacrifice Moses commanded.

  • Pingback: Weekend Links | Worship Links()

  • Consumer debt (non-mortgage debt) is crippling the church. I recently read a stat that about 2-3% of all evengelical americans actually “tithe”. That stat is probably a little low for my congregation, however the consumer debt is an issue.

  • Kay Lynn Harris Jones

    On tithing, I heard a pastor say he understood why is members didn’t tithe. The cost of living has gone up and salaries have either stayed the same or gone down yet the tithing has stayed the same 10%. His church was in the position of either tithe or feed my kids. opinion please on this thinking.

    • Paul

      Hello Kay,

      My wife and I were at this crossroads at the beginning of 2015 when we heard something Bill Hybels said that made so much sense. Basically there are only two types of people when it comes to tithing, and they are both idiots; the idiots who tithe and the idiots who don’t. Both sides see the other side as an idiot for what they see as irrational behavior. The real choice is, which idiot will you be? (We’ve been both!)

      • Mahala77

        where is a like button , when you need one? great point Paul!

  • Pingback: Miscellaneous Links | JLP Pastor()

  • Pingback: Charles Stone > Top 10 Reasons People Don’t Tithe | Innovate For Jesus | Grow the Church()

  • Great post, Charles. I particularly enjoyed point three, spirituality hasn’t been downgraded. I also find it hard to use the law as a reason to tithe or not to tithe; either way, Jesus eliminated the curse of the law but not the sense of it. Tithing is still a good idea if a person wants to be a contributor.

    • Thx Ennis. Thanks for your comment.

    • Bruce Nicola Jr.

      When I read Malachi 3:8-10 I don’t hear God saying tithing and giving offerings are simply “a good idea.” The message of Malachi is much stronger than that. And if you liked #3 then you would have to agree that tithing is much more important that just a good idea.

  • Pingback: The Top 10 Leadership Posts I Read The Week Of January 2nd | Brian Dodd on Leadership()

  • Terry Dorsett

    Charles, may I have permission to repost this on my blog? http://www.terrydorsett.com

    • Sure, just please use appropriate attribution. Thx

    • Yes you can. Just please use appropriate attribution. Thx

      • Terry Dorsett

        Great, thanks! It will run one day next week with a link back to this post and a small bio from your biography page.

  • SAHuisvrou

    Been tithing a long time on our bruto.

    But going through financial difficult times right now. Our country is in an economical recession, our income stayed the same for four consecutive years now, despite high inflation rates. During this time, I’ve been diagnosed with an autoimmune disease which puts tremendous stress on our finances due to medications, blood tests and dietary changes.

    All this really makes cutting on the tithe a huge temptation….not that we did or will consider, just that sometimes going through financial turmoil can cause people to cut back or altogether stop giving.

    • Thanks for sharing and I agree that sometimes extenuating circumstances can affect our giving.

  • Sumit Joshi

    some people dont tithe because they think that the church is rich
    church has lots of money …Pastor is rich enough …